Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake

Introduction & Inspiration

Finding the perfect birthday cake recipe can feel like a lifelong quest. I’m always searching for that ultimate combination of a moist, tender crumb, rich vanilla flavor, and a frosting that’s sweet but balanced. This “Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake” recipe, with its specific techniques like reverse creaming and a unique frosting blend including cream cheese and shortening, immediately signaled that it might just be the one.

My inspiration comes from the pure joy associated with a classic birthday cake – the sprinkles, the candles, the celebratory feel. I wanted to explore a recipe that promised not just a good cake, but the best, utilizing techniques designed for a professional-bakery-quality result at home. The inclusion of vanilla bean paste hinted at a truly exceptional vanilla flavor.

My goal was to delve into this detailed recipe, understand the “why” behind methods like using cold butter in the dry ingredients, and share the process for creating what could be the ultimate homemade birthday cake. It involves several steps and specific ingredients, but the promise of perfection makes it an exciting baking project.

Let’s embark on this journey to create the Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake!

Nostalgic Appeal

This cake, while using sophisticated techniques, taps directly into the core nostalgia of a classic American birthday cake. The prominent vanilla flavor, the tender buttermilk crumb, and especially the sprinkles mixed right into the frosting scream “celebration” and evoke happy memories of childhood parties.

The combination of a vanilla cake with a slightly tangy, sweet frosting is a timeless favorite. While this frosting includes unique elements like shortening and corn syrup for texture and stability, the underlying cream cheese tang provides a familiar counterpoint to the sweetness, reminiscent of classic cream cheese frostings.

The visual appeal, with sprinkles studding the frosting and an optional decorative border, is pure birthday fun. It looks like the kind of cake you’d eagerly anticipate cutting into at a party.

Making this cake feels like creating a new classic, grounded in the comforting nostalgia of birthday traditions but elevated with thoughtful techniques and ingredients.

Homemade Focus (Technique Driven)

This Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake recipe is a fantastic example of how specific homemade techniques can elevate a simple concept to something extraordinary. It goes beyond basic mixing, employing methods often used by professional bakers to achieve a specific, desirable texture and stability.

The recipe utilizes a variation of the reverse creaming method for the cake batter – incorporating cold butter into the dry ingredients first. This technique coats the flour with fat, inhibiting gluten development and resulting in an exceptionally tender, fine crumb. It’s a deliberate, homemade approach focused on texture.

Similarly, the frosting isn’t a simple buttercream. It’s a carefully constructed blend of butter, shortening (for stability and texture), cream cheese (for tang), corn syrup and glucose (for smoothness and preventing crystallization), and vanilla bean paste. Crafting this complex frosting from scratch is key to the cake’s unique character and professional finish.

From precisely measuring ingredients (grams are provided for accuracy) to the multi-step frosting process and careful assembly, this recipe highlights the rewarding results that come from focused, technique-driven homemade baking.

Flavor Goal

The primary flavor goal of this Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake is a perfectly balanced, rich, and moist vanilla cake with a tangy, sweet, and incredibly smooth frosting, punctuated by the fun texture and subtle flavor of sprinkles. It aims for the ultimate celebratory vanilla cake experience.

The cake layers, utilizing cake flour, buttermilk, both butter and oil, and extra egg yolks, are designed for maximum tenderness, moisture, and rich flavor. The vanilla bean paste ensures a deep, aromatic vanilla presence.

The unique “Birthday Cake” frosting aims for the perfect balance of sweetness (powdered sugar), tang (cream cheese, lemon extract/citric acid), richness (butter, shortening), and smoothness (corn syrup/glucose). The clear vanilla maintains brightness, and the salt enhances all flavors.

The sprinkles mixed into the final frosting layer add visual appeal and a slight textural crunch, reinforcing the birthday theme. The optional turquoise border adds a final decorative touch. The overall effect is intended to be the quintessential, celebratory “birthday cake” flavor profile, executed perfectly.

Ingredient Insights

Let’s examine the roles of the key ingredients in this carefully crafted recipe:

For the Buttermilk Cake layers:

• Cake flour: Essential for a tender, fine crumb due to its lower protein content.
• Superfine sugar (or Golden Caster Sugar): Dissolves quickly and easily for smooth batter.
• Baking powder & Baking soda: Leavening agents.
• Salt: Flavor enhancer.
• COLD unsalted butter, cut into pieces: Key to the reverse creaming method, coating flour to limit gluten.
• Buttermilk (room temperature): Adds moisture, tang, and activates baking soda.
• Vanilla bean paste (or seeds/extract): Provides deep vanilla flavor.
• Almond extract (Pure): Adds a subtle complexity often found in “birthday cake” flavors.
• Eggs (room temperature): Structure, richness, binding.

For the Birthday Cake frosting:

• Unsalted butter (room temperature) & Vegetable shortening: Butter for flavor, shortening for stability and texture (prevents melting too easily).
• Clear corn syrup & Glucose (optional but recommended): Liquid sugars that create a smoother, glossier frosting and prevent crystallization.
• Pure vanilla extract & Lemon extract (or Citric Acid): Vanilla for flavor, lemon/citric acid for the signature tang that cuts sweetness.
• Confectioners’ sugar, sifted: Sweetness and structure.
• Fine salt: Balances sweetness.
• Cream cheese, softened: Adds significant tangy flavor and creaminess.
• Sprinkles (jimmies & coated chips recommended): Mixed into the final frosting layer for the funfetti effect and texture.
• Turquoise gel color (optional): For the decorative border.

Using room temperature ingredients where specified (but cold butter for the cake itself) and sifting the powdered sugar are crucial.

Essential Equipment

This recipe benefits from specific tools for best results:

• Three 8 x 2-inch round cake pans: The recipe is designed for three layers. The recommended Fat Daddio’s pans are high quality.
• Parchment paper rounds:
• Stand mixer with paddle attachment: Highly recommended for both the reverse creaming cake method and the complex, long-beating frosting.
• Medium measuring cup with spout: For combining some wet ingredients.
• Large bowls:
• Whisk:
• Rubber spatula:
• Serrated knife: For leveling cake layers.
• Offset palette knife & Straight palette knife: For applying frosting smoothly.
• Cake turntable (optional but highly recommended): For easier frosting.
• 18″ piping bag & Piping tip Ateco #887 (large closed star): For the decorative border.
• Measuring cups, spoons, and ideally a kitchen scale.

A stand mixer and offset/straight spatulas are particularly helpful for this cake.

List of Ingredients with Measurements

Here’s the complete list of ingredients, with precise measurements (using provided weights where available):

For the Buttermilk Cake layers:

• 1-2 tablespoons each, butter and flour for preparing the cake tins
• 3 cups (350g) cake flour
• 2 cups (400g) superfine sugar (or golden caster sugar)
• 1 tbsp + 1 tsp baking powder
• 3/4 tsp salt
• 1 cup (227g/2 sticks) cold unsalted butter, cut into pieces
• 1 1/2 cups (360ml) buttermilk, room temperature (divided: 1 cup & 1/2 cup)
• 2 tsp (10ml) vanilla bean paste or pure vanilla extract
• 1/4 tsp pure almond extract
• 5 whole eggs, room temperature

For the Birthday Cake frosting:

• 1 cups (230g/2 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature
• 1/2 cup (100g) vegetable shortening
• 3 tbsp (45ml) clear corn syrup
• 1 tbsp (15ml) pure vanilla extract
• 1/8 tsp lemon extract (or pinch citric acid)
• 2 1/2 cups (400g) confectioners’ sugar, sifted
• 1/2 tsp fine salt
• Pinch baking powder (.38g)
• 1/2 cup (110g) cream cheese, softened
• 1/2 cup (4oz) sprinkles, preferably jimmies + coated chips
• Few drops turquoise gel color (optional)

Ensure ingredients are at the specified temperatures (cold butter for cake, room temp for frosting).

Step-by-Step Instructions (Elaborated)

Let’s walk through this detailed process:

Make the Buttermilk Cake Layers:

1. Preheat & Prep Pans: Preheat oven to 350°F (180°C). Grease bottoms of three 8×2-inch round cake pans, line with parchment rounds, and grease the parchment.
2. Combine Dry Ingredients & Butter (Reverse Creaming): In the bowl of an electric mixer with the paddle attachment, whisk together the cake flour, superfine sugar, baking powder, and salt. With the mixer on low speed, add the cold butter pieces one at a time. Beat until all butter is incorporated and the mixture resembles fine cornmeal, about 3 minutes.
3. Combine Wet Ingredients: In a medium measuring cup with a spout, combine 1 cup of the room temperature buttermilk, the vanilla, and the almond extract. In a separate measuring cup, gently whisk the room temperature eggs with the remaining 1/2 cup buttermilk.
4. Add Liquids (Part 1): Increase mixer speed to medium-low. Gradually add the vanilla/buttermilk mixture (from the first cup) to the dry ingredients. Beat for 5 minutes. Scrape the bowl well.
5. Add Liquids (Part 2): Reduce mixer speed to low. Gradually add the egg/buttermilk mixture in three additions, scraping the bowl after each. Beat until well combined, about 2 minutes total.
6. Final Fold & Bake: Fold the batter once or twice with a spatula to ensure everything is incorporated. Divide batter evenly among the prepared pans. Bake in the center of the oven for 20 to 22 minutes, or until a wooden pick inserted into the center comes out with a few moist crumbs.
7. Cool: Let cake layers cool in pans on wire racks for 10 minutes. Loosen sides with a knife and carefully turn cakes out onto racks. Peel off parchment and let cool completely. Wrap cooled layers tightly in plastic wrap; can be stored at room temp for up to 3 days.

Make the Birthday Cake Frosting:

1. Cream Butter & Shortening: Combine room temperature butter and shortening in the stand mixer bowl (paddle attachment). Beat on medium-high for about 3 minutes until creamy and fluffy. Scrape bowl.
2. Add Liquid Sugars & Extracts: With mixer on low, stream in the corn syrup, vanilla extract, and lemon extract (or citric acid). Turn mixer to medium-high and beat for 3 minutes until smooth and glossy white. Scrape bowl.
3. Add Dry Ingredients: Add the sifted confectioners’ sugar and salt. Beat on low speed until incorporated.
4. Whip Frosting: Turn mixer back up to medium-high and beat for 3 more minutes until shiny, creamy, and smooth.
5. Add Cream Cheese: Add the softened cream cheese and beat on medium speed just until combined, about 1 minute. Do not over-beat at this stage.

Assemble the Buttermilk Birthday Cake:

1. Prepare Frosting & Sprinkles: Reserve about 2 cups of the white frosting for tinting/piping. Gently stir the 1/2 cup of sprinkles into the remaining white frosting (the portion you’ll use for filling and the final coat).
2. Level Cakes: Trim the cooled cake layers if needed for flat surfaces.
3. First Layer: Place one cake layer, top up, on a cake board or plate (reserve the best-looking layer for the top). Using a small offset palette knife, spread 1 1/4 cups of the sprinkle-filled frosting evenly over the top, extending slightly past the edge.
4. Repeat Layers: Add the second cake layer and repeat the frosting/sprinkle application. Place the final cake layer on top, bottom side up (for a flat top surface).
5. Crumb Coat: Using a straight palette knife, smooth the frosting protruding from between the layers onto the sides of the cake. Apply a thin layer of the sprinkle frosting over the entire cake to seal in crumbs. Chill for 15 minutes.
6. Final Frosting Coat: Remove cake from the fridge. Apply a smooth, thick final layer of the sprinkle-filled frosting over the chilled crumb coat.
7. Tint and Pipe Border (Optional): Tint the reserved 2 cups of frosting with a few drops of turquoise gel color. Fit an 18″ pastry bag with a large closed star tip (Ateco #887). Fill the bag with the turquoise frosting and pipe a decorative border around the top perimeter of the cake.
8. Serve/Store: The cake will keep at room temperature for up to 12 hours. Refrigerate for longer storage (up to 3 days), but serve at room temperature if possible for best texture.

This assembly creates the signature look with sprinkles in the frosting.

Troubleshooting

This cake involves specific techniques; here are potential issues:

• Cake Texture Issues (Dense/Dry): Incorrect butter temperature (must be cold for reverse creaming). Overmixing after adding liquids. Inaccurate flour measurement. Overbaking.
• Frosting Curdled/Split: Often due to temperature differences between fats (butter, shortening, cream cheese). Ensure all are properly softened room temp before starting frosting. The liquid sugars help stability, but if it splits, try the gentle warming/cooling methods. Do not over-beat after adding cream cheese.
• Frosting Too Thin/Soft: Cream cheese wasn’t properly softened (still cold) or was over-beaten after addition. Insufficient powdered sugar. Kitchen too warm. Chill frosting briefly.
• Frosting Grainy: Powdered sugar wasn’t sifted.
• Assembly Difficulty: Cake layers not fully cooled or chilled before frosting. Frosting too soft. Use an offset spatula and turntable for easier frosting.

Follow temperatures and mixing instructions carefully!

Tips and Variations

Let’s enhance this celebratory cake:

• Tip: Using cake flour and room temperature buttermilk/eggs is crucial for the cake’s tender texture.
• Variation: Omit the almond and lemon extracts for a pure vanilla birthday cake flavor.
• Tip: If you don’t have clear corn syrup or glucose, you can omit them, but the frosting texture might be slightly less smooth and stable.
• Variation: Use different types or colors of sprinkles! Check Sweetapolita’s shop (as mentioned) for unique medleys.
• Tip: A kitchen scale provides the most accurate measurements, highly recommended for this recipe.
• Variation: Add a thin layer of fruit jam (like raspberry) between the cake layers along with the frosting.

Make it your ultimate birthday creation!

Serving and Pairing Suggestions

This Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake is designed for celebrations!

Serving: Serve slices at room temperature for the best cake and frosting texture. If refrigerated, let it sit out for 20-30 minutes before slicing.

Pairing:

• Perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, or any festive occasion.
• A tall glass of cold milk is the ultimate classic pairing.
• Coffee or tea works well too.
• For adults, a glass of champagne or Prosecco feels suitably celebratory. Drink with moderation.

It’s a centerpiece dessert that brings joy!

Nutritional Information

This is a rich, multi-layer cake with a complex frosting. Nutritional information is approximate and depends heavily on slice size. A slice (assuming 12-16 slices) might contain:

• Calories: 600-800+
• Fat: 35-50+ grams
• Saturated Fat: 18-28+ grams
• Cholesterol: 100-150+ mg
• Sodium: 250-400+ mg
• Total Carbs.: 70-90+ grams
• Dietary Fiber: 1-2 grams
• Sugars: 55-75+ grams
• Protein: 5-8 grams

This is a very indulgent cake, perfect for celebrations and best enjoyed in moderation.

Print

Recipe Summary and Q&A

Let’s conclude with a summary and FAQs based on the recipe and notes:

Recipe Summary:

The Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake features three layers of tender vanilla cake made using a reverse creaming method with buttermilk and vanilla bean paste. It’s frosted with a unique, stable frosting combining butter, shortening, cream cheese, corn syrup, and lemon extract, with sprinkles mixed throughout and an optional decorative turquoise border.

Q&A:

Q: Can I make this cake ahead of time? A: Yes. The recipe notes cake layers can be wrapped and stored at room temp for 3 days. Frosting can be made a week ahead (refrigerate, bring to temp & re-whip). The assembled cake can be kept for a day at cool room temp or up to 3 days refrigerated (serve at room temp).

Q: How should I store the finished cake? A: Store covered at cool room temperature for up to 12 hours, or refrigerated for up to 3 days. Let it come to room temperature before serving for best texture.

Q: Why use cold butter in the cake batter? A: This is part of the reverse creaming method. Coating the flour with cold fat inhibits gluten development, leading to a very tender, fine crumb.

Q: Can I substitute ingredients in the frosting (like omit shortening or corn syrup)? A: You can, but the texture, stability, and flavor profile will change. These ingredients are specifically chosen for the signature Momofuku/Sweetapolita-style frosting. Substituting will result in a more standard buttercream or cream cheese frosting.

Q: Can I use 9-inch pans? A: Yes, the notes mention 8 or 9-inch pans. If using 9-inch, you’ll likely get two slightly thicker layers instead of three thinner ones, and baking time may need adjustment.

I hope this detailed guide helps you bake what might just become your “Best Buttermilk Birthday Cake”! It’s a wonderful project with delicious results. Happy Baking!